Racist and Sexist Ads by IceBreakers Merino Wool

http://www.adventureinc.co.za/wp-content/themes/adventureinc/images/showcase_icebreaker.jpg

I ran across one of these ads for in a window display the other day and almost walked into a telephone pole in shock. I’m pretty sure that they’ve covered every single racialized sexual stereotype you could ever think of, just to sell some hardcore mountaineering merino wool products. Let’s see:

Black people are like animals and more in touch with nature than white people? Check.

Black men are significantly more virile than any other men? Check.

Women’s power comes exclusively from their sexuality and dominating a man is the ultimate expression of such? Check.

A white woman dominating a black man is even more impressive, as white women are naturally frail, and meant for having babies, not gaining pleasure out of sex? Check.

In these images, Icebreakers places ram’s heads on black men’s bodies, demonstrating how their only worth is their physicality, considering that they quite literally have sheep’s brains. We see very thin white women riding them or shearing them (which coincidentally looks quite a lot like castrating–again with the sexual domination), and we are expected to understand that the relationship between these women and these sheep-men represents our powerful and beneficial connection to nature, not our long history of slavery and white people using black bodies for their own benefit.

Even more revolting is that the New Zealand-based company is very vocal about their company ethics. According to their website:

“Customers increasingly care about where the things they buy come from. They want to know about the ethical commitment of the companies they buy from, and what impact their purchases will have on the planet.”

Icebreakers is all about the environment. If you sign up for the emailing list, they plant a tree. The inks they use to print the packaging for their products are vegetable-based. They ship only by sea, and maintain a commitment to low-intensity farming to protect the fragile ecosystems of New Zealand. Their factories are required to provide their workers a “caring community environment,” natural light, and clean air. They promise their sheep “freedom from distress” and the “ability to display normal patterns of behavior.” Heck, even their sheep dogs are guaranteed rights!

But what about the people affected by the ads they send out? What about their right to “freedom from distress” or the “ability to display normal patterns of behavior?” How many black men wear ram’s horns on your average day?

The site is full of these contradictions, vague commitments to “a sustainable business model that doesn’t put profits ahead of the environment” while completely prioritizing profits over decades of progress in racial and gender equity.

I get it. Sex sells. Their ad certainly stopped me in my tracks and got me to spend an hour looking at their site. But I left it revolted. I think there is a line that was crossed way back when they started peppering their site with random facts like “Did you know that a single merino ram can service several hundred ewes in a season–they’re often begging to be let out of the field when mating season is over.”

Ads like these perpetuate harmful stereotypes about women’s and people of color’s worth and power. Though sex is beautiful in all its forms, we are both more than our sexuality and sex is not our only connection to nature. We are intelligent, cognizant beings, and we don’t appreciate being represented in any other way.

Who’s with me? Let’s tell them:

To email the U.S. office: cs@icebreaker.com

To call the U.S. office: 866-363-7466

Click here to contact other international offices:

Their Facebook page (please don’t Like them!)

Their Twitter account.

 

http://strengthrunning.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Wool-Man.jpghttp://www.beautiful-email-newsletters.com/images/newsletters/Icebreaker-Pure-New-Zealand-Merino-dec-09.pnghttp://demandware.edgesuite.net/aafx_prd/on/demandware.static/Sites-IB-US-Site/Sites-IB-US-Library/en/v1345144321667/images/ss12/superduper/shop-main.jpg

That wasn’t enough? Check out this photo of their store opening in San Francisco (the window display that I saw).

 

 

23. August 2012 by Juliana
Categories: Race | Tags: , , , , , | 9 comments

  • Icebreaker

    Dear Juliana

    We are concerned that you have found our
    advertising offensive and inconsistent with our philosophy.

    Racial and gender representatives are a
    sensitive issue in marketing, and the last thing we would ever want to do is to
    promote negative or damaging stereotypes of anyone.

    The figure with the merino ram’s head that
    you have seen in our advertising is a symbolic figure we call the Ramotaur.

    Our garments are made from natural,
    renewable merino wool, and sustainable production methods are at the core of
    our business.  The Ramotaur figure was
    created as a symbol of the connection our product has with nature, and is not
    intended to be human but an imaginary, half-merino figure. We believe the ram’s
    head makes it clear that this figure is mythical rather than human.

    The models we use for Ramo, the promotional
    figure who represents Ramotaur, are always ethnically diverse as again the last
    thing we would want to do is promote a negative or damaging sterotype.

    None of our images are intended to show women
    in decorative or passive roles. The women and men in our images are equally
    confident, adventurous and active. In our product photographs, for example,
    women are portrayed taking part in the same activities as men, with the same
    degree of activity and athleticism.

    We are very sorry to hear your concerns.
    But please rest assured that the imagery that concerns you was created as a
    symbol of Icebreaker’s connection with nature, and that we intended no racial
    or gender subtext.

    We do value your
    comments, and take all feedback into consideration when planning future
    imagery. 

    - Icebreaker

  • Giuliana

    Dear icebreaker,

    Forgive me but your response appears to be a jargon-driven advertisement of your own product that only reinforces the stereotyped depictions of race and gender that Juliana has so eloquently outlined.

    You are pretending that you are interested in ethnic diversity yet you have exclusively used black men and white women. As advertising professionals I know that’s not a coincidence. You know tired colonial connotations as well as I do and an image of a blonde white woman shearing a black half animal male is not simply an image relating to merino wool and nature. Even if this was a misguided mistake (which it wasn’t), it’s a crass and disrespectful inference to slavery and colonialism.

    You did not reference the sexual objectification at the centre of your ad campaign. This is a lazy and unoriginal way of selling a product and undermines whatever alleged philosophy you claim to adhere to.

    Needless to say, I will not be buying any of your products.

  • felixHcat

    Your comments about race don’t really hold water… a little bit of digging reveals an ethnically diverse group of male models.

    http://www.izzatdesign.com/portfolio/large/icebreaker%20model%20standing%20with%20prosthetic.shtml
    http://demandware.edgesuite.net/aafx_prd/on/demandware.static/Sites-IB-CA-Site/Sites-IB-CA-Library/en/v1345823949512/images/ss12/superduper/shop-main.jpg

    http://www.leckenby.co.uk/clients/icebreaker-touch-lab_files/fullpath_10.jpg

    The gender roles bit may prove to be more problematic but I think your comments about race may be a little hypersensitive(?) 

  • Julianabritto

    Yes, FelixHCat, there are ads where the men of color are not necessarily black. However, they are still men of color, and the women are still white. So I would argue that my comments about race are still quite relevant.

  • Julianabritto

    Dear Icebreaker,

    Thank you for your respectful reply, however, to be quite frank, I don’t believe a word of it.

    The models you use to represent the Ramataur are not “ethnically diverse,” they are 80% black men and 100% men of color, and you are therefore continuing to “promote a negative AND damaging stereotype.”

    And your women may be equally active in your product photographs, but in your Ramataur ad campaign, they most certainly are not.

    Giuliana makes some great points in her comment. I agree that though images like this certainly attract attention, a company with such high morals embedded in its philosophy could surely do better. If your product is so eco-friendly, then won’t people use it whether or not you draw on images of slavery and sexual submission in your ads? I would hope you have that much faith in your product.

    Though the Ramataur may have been “created as a symbol of Icebreaker’s connection with nature,” I don’t believe for a minute that you “intended no racial or gender subtext.” Please. Don’t patronize me.

  • Kbass

    THANK you for such an insightful post! I agree on absolutely all accounts.

  • warsaw

    Juliana, Do you think that the black male model is incapable of making decisions for himself?

    You complain that the ad depicts a white woman dominating a black man. Yet you are a young Brazilian woman that feels she can dictate winch job a black man can do. Get real. Stop treating people as if they are inferior to yourself.

    In Julian’s world all black men should first check with her before getting hired. Or better yet, we don’t want to discriminate so let’s not hire black men for any job.

  • Jacob

    Julian,

    You’ve missed the point, the ‘black’ or overly tanned
    individual is a massive 15 foot tall ram! kudos to him for being awesome. If I ever become a 15 foot tall ram my life will be complete! (Assuming the attractive female is a part of the package)

    [Icebreaker, I’ve got your back! Your artwork is beautiful,
    keep it up!]

    Jake

  • Jan

    Juliana… dont you think your strong resonance only shows that all theproblems about races and sexes are first of all in your own mind.

    In the end you blame icebreaker for being a racist and sexist company and tell people to not buy it although for real you are racist and sexist yourself. As when I see the ads I just think theyre pretty and I dont care if Ramotaur is black, white, yellow, red or blue.